Imagine walking into the kitchen and finding your mother trying to eat a tissue.
You gently take it from her hand. She looks at you, confused. Perhaps even upset.
You wonder why she would do something like that.
But what if, in that moment, she genuinely doesn't recognise that the tissue isn't food?
For families caring for someone living with dementia, experiences like this can be frightening, confusing and difficult to talk about. They are often hidden out of embarrassment, or dismissed as simply another part of dementia.
Yet these behaviours deserve understanding, not judgement. Sometimes, what appears to be unusual behaviour is a sign that something deeper needs attention.
What Is Pica?
Pica is the persistent eating of substances that are not food and have no nutritional value, such as paper, soil, chalk, soap or other household materials. The name comes from the Latin word for magpie, a bird traditionally associated with collecting a wide variety of objects.
Not every instance of eating or mouthing objects in dementia is clinically classified as pica. Whatever the label, the cause is often the same. Dementia affects the brain's ability to recognise objects, make judgements and control impulses, so someone may mistake an everyday object for food, or put something in their mouth without understanding the danger.
Changes in eating behaviour, including altered food preferences and compulsive eating, are particularly noticeable in some forms of dementia, such as frontotemporal dementia. They can appear unexpectedly, come and go, or become more frequent over time.
What matters most is recognising that the person may not understand what they are doing, or why it could be unsafe.
Seeing the World Through Their Eyes
It is natural to ask, "Why on earth is Mum doing this?" A more helpful question is: "What is Mum experiencing?"
When we consider how dementia changes the way someone experiences the world, behaviours that first seem incomprehensible begin to make sense.
Objects stop being what they seem
Dementia can affect the brain's ability to recognise familiar objects, even when eyesight is good. Something obviously inedible to us can look like food to someone whose perception has changed. A bar of soap can be mistaken for something edible. A brightly coloured dishwasher tablet can look just like a sweet.
Taste and smell change
Dementia often alters taste, smell and food preferences. Favourite meals lose their appeal, while particular flavours, textures or sensations become newly interesting, and this can draw someone towards things that aren't food.
Hunger and thirst become hard to recognise
Someone living with dementia can feel discomfort without knowing it means they are hungry or thirsty. They may also struggle to find, or identify, something appropriate to eat.
Boredom, anxiety and the need for comfort
Chewing or mouthing objects can provide comfort and sensory stimulation. Restlessness, anxiety, unfamiliar surroundings and a lack of meaningful activity all play a part.
Physical and medical factors
Not every change in eating behaviour is caused directly by dementia. Dental discomfort, mouth pain, nutritional deficiencies, medication effects and other medical conditions can all contribute. This is why new or persistent behaviours should be discussed with a healthcare professional rather than automatically put down to dementia.
Behaviour offers important clues. Our task is to look beyond what we see and consider what the person is experiencing.
Beyond Pica: Other Changes at the Table
Eating things that aren't food is one of the more alarming changes families encounter, but dementia can affect a person's relationship with food in many other ways. Families and carers may notice someone:
Forgetting that a meal has just been eaten and asking for another
Forgetting to eat, or leaving meals untouched
Hiding or hoarding food in drawers, handbags or pockets
Eating food that has spoiled, or taking food from other people's plates
Developing a sudden preference for sweet foods
Refusing meals that were once favourites
Struggling to recognise or use cutlery
Eating very quickly or taking unusually large mouthfuls
Holding food in the mouth without swallowing
These changes have different causes, including memory difficulties, changes in appetite, reduced coordination, altered perception and swallowing problems. Some appear gradually; others arrive unexpectedly.
Something as familiar and comforting as sharing a meal can become confusing, frustrating or even unsafe. Recognising these changes early helps families find the right support and make mealtimes more comfortable.
Responding With Compassion, Not Confrontation
When you notice someone you love reaching for something unsafe, your immediate instinct may be to snatch it away. That reaction is understandable. But for a person living with dementia, sudden intervention can cause fear, confusion or distress, particularly if they don't understand why the object is being taken from them.
Where there is no immediate danger, a calm and reassuring response is usually more helpful.
Swap, don't scold
Gently redirect their attention towards something safe and familiar. Offering a suitable snack, or inviting them to join another activity, often works well.
However, if the person has already swallowed something potentially harmful, seek medical or poisons advice before offering any food or drink.
Keep suitable foods within reach
For someone who often reaches for objects or enjoys nibbling, accessible snacks or finger foods can help. These should suit the person's dietary needs and swallowing ability, with supervision where required.
Offer food and drink regularly
Smaller, more frequent meals and regular drinks help when someone has difficulty recognising or communicating hunger and thirst.
Make food easier to recognise
Plates that contrast with the food, an uncluttered table and familiar meals all help someone recognise what is being served.
Encourage meaningful activity
Gentle companionship, familiar routines and enjoyable activities reduce boredom and restlessness. Sensory activities can be useful too, provided nothing involved creates a choking or swallowing risk.
Look for patterns
Does the behaviour happen before meals? When the person is tired? During periods of anxiety or restlessness?
Keeping a simple record of when it occurs, what objects are involved and what happened beforehand can help families and healthcare professionals identify triggers.
The person is not being difficult, childish or deliberately challenging. They are trying to make sense of a world that has become increasingly confusing, and their dignity should remain at the centre of every response.
Making the Home Safer
Understanding the behaviour matters, but so does reducing the risk of harm. A few thoughtful changes can make the home safer without making it feel unfamiliar or institutional.
Secure cleaning products. Keep laundry pods, dishwasher tablets, bleach and household chemicals locked away. Brightly coloured products are particularly misleading.
Store medicines safely. Keep prescription medicines, medicines bought without a prescription, vitamins, creams and eye drops securely stored.
Remove small hazardous objects. Keep batteries, coins, buttons and other small items out of reach.
Check plants and gardening products. Some houseplants, garden plants and gardening chemicals are harmful if swallowed.
Keep toiletries secure. Soap, toothpaste, cosmetics and other bathroom products may need to be stored out of sight.
Monitor food storage. Check the fridge and cupboards regularly for spoiled or unsafe food.
Secure pet products. Store pet food, pet medications and cleaning products safely.
Safety arrangements should reflect the individual's abilities, routines and level of risk, while preserving as much independence as possible.
What if someone swallows something harmful?
If you suspect someone has swallowed a potentially poisonous substance, seek professional advice immediately. Do not induce vomiting or give food or drink unless a healthcare professional advises it.
In Ireland, the National Poisons Information Centre runs the Public Poisons Information Line on 01 809 2166, from 8am to 10pm, seven days a week.
If the person is choking, having difficulty breathing, becomes seriously unwell or is experiencing a medical emergency, call 112 or 999 immediately.
When Should You Speak to the GP?
Any new, persistent or changing eating behaviour deserves attention, and it is important not to assume that every change is simply part of dementia. A GP can assess possible contributing factors, including:
Nutritional deficiencies
Dental or mouth pain
Constipation or other physical discomfort
Infection or a sudden change in health
Medication side effects
Changes in cognition or behaviour
Depending on the person's needs, the GP may recommend further assessment or referrals. A speech and language therapist can assess swallowing difficulties, while a dietitian can help with nutritional concerns, weight changes or restricted eating patterns.
If someone is coughing or choking during meals, holding food in their mouth or struggling to swallow, prompt professional assessment is particularly important.
Families should not have to work through these concerns alone. The Alzheimer Society of Ireland provides information, guidance and emotional support through its confidential National Helpline on 1800 341 341, Monday to Friday from 10am to 5pm, and Saturday from 10am to 4pm.
The Quiet Power of Being There
Sometimes, the smallest changes in behaviour deserve our greatest attention.
A hand reaching for something unsafe. A meal left untouched. A familiar routine suddenly becoming unfamiliar.
These moments remind us that compassionate dementia care is about more than help with daily tasks. It is about knowing the person, recognising change, and responding with patience, understanding and respect.
Pica and other unusual eating behaviours are rarely resolved by one simple intervention. Supporting someone takes consistent observation, thoughtful adjustments and good communication between families, carers and healthcare professionals.
This is where attentive, personalised care at home makes a meaningful difference. A dedicated live-in carer who understands a person's routines, preferences and changing needs can help maintain a safer environment, offer reassurance and recognise when additional support is needed. Just as importantly, familiar surroundings and a trusted relationship help a person living with dementia feel comfortable and secure.
At Royal Homecare, we believe everyone deserves to feel safe, respected and understood in the place they call home. We carefully match families with experienced carers who bring not only practical skills, but patience, compassion and genuine warmth. If you are caring for someone whose relationship with food is changing, we would be glad to talk through how personalised live-in care could support your loved one and your family.
Because sometimes, the most important part of caring is understanding what someone can no longer explain.
Useful Contacts and Further Support
The Alzheimer Society of Ireland: National Helpline 1800 341 341. Visit the Alzheimer Society of Ireland
National Poisons Information Centre: Public Poisons Information Line 01 809 2166, 8am to 10pm, seven days a week. Visit the National Poisons Information Centre
Emergency Services (Ireland): 112 or 999
Disclaimer: This article is intended for general information and awareness. It does not replace medical advice, diagnosis or treatment. If you are concerned about unusual eating behaviours in someone living with dementia, consult an appropriate healthcare professional.

